The Visibility Index
Home / The Index / Local
The discipline the answer layer has not touched

Who holds the insurance map pack, metro by metro

Twelve near-me insurance searches, run in 109 metros. A Local Pack appeared on almost every capture and an AI Overview on 6.3%. This is where the phone calls come from, and it is contested by local businesses rather than by national carriers.

Median rating, US metros 4.9 · Canada 4.6 · 1,011 businesses across 3,923 slots

United States

99 metros
Insurance local pack summary by metro, August 2026
MetroHolds the most slots SlotsBusinessesMedian rating
Albany Brick House Insurance Agency 36 7 4.9
Albuquerque Freeway Insurance 33 10 4.9
Allentown Acceptance Insurance 36 5 4.9
Anaheim Anaheim Insurance & Vehicle 36 9 4.9
Arlington La Familia Auto Insurance 36 10 4.9
Atlanta Elsie Affordable Auto Insurance Atlanta 36 9 4.8
Aurora Affordable Insurance 36 10 4.3
Austin Acceptance Insurance 36 11 4.8
Bakersfield InsureOne Insurance 36 10 4.8
Baltimore Baltimore Insurance Network 36 9 4.9
Baton Rouge Archangel Insurance 36 10 4.9
Birmingham All American Insurance 36 8 5
Boise Bryant Auto Insurance 36 10 4.9
Boston Bender Hatch Insurance 36 6 4.9
Bridgeport CRN Insurance Agency 36 6 4.7
Buffalo Willoughby Insurance 36 7 4.8
Cape Coral Simily Insurance 36 8 4.9
Chandler Acceptance Insurance 36 9 4.8
Charlotte Latorre Insurance 36 9 4.9
Chicago Lincoln Auto Insurance 36 8 4.9
Cincinnati Camargo Insurance 36 11 4.9
Cleveland CrossCountry Home and Auto Insurance Agency 36 6 4.9
Colorado Springs A Plus Insurance 36 9 4.95
Columbia Insurance Company Advisors Group of Columbia 36 9 5
Columbus Branch 36 10 4.8
Corpus Christi Acceptance Insurance 36 9 4.9
Dallas Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service 36 13 4.9
Denver Denver Insurance LLC 36 14 4.9
Des Moines The Insurance Specialists Inc 36 9 4.8
Detroit L.A. Insurance 36 9 4.9
El Paso Mt. Franklin Insurance 36 11 4.9
Eugene Affordable Insurance Solutions 36 11 4.85
Fort Lauderdale Estrella Insurance 36 8 4.9
Fort Worth General Motors Insurance 38 13 4.9
Fresno Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service 36 6 4.9
Grand Rapids West Michigan Insurance, Inc. 36 8 4.9
Harrisburg Kind Insurance 36 5 4.800000000000001
Hartford 72 Main Insurance 36 7 4.25
Henderson Freeway Insurance 36 9 4.9
Houston Pasadena Insurance Agency, Inc. 36 16 4.8
Indianapolis Acceptance Insurance 36 9 4.9
Jackson Acceptance Insurance 36 7 4.9
Jacksonville Acceptance Insurance 36 8 4.7
Jersey City Freeway Insurance 36 11 4.9
Kansas City Freeway Insurance 36 12 4.8
Lansing Rathbun Insurance 36 6 4.65
Laredo A-MAX Auto Insurance 36 9 4.7
Las Vegas Affordable Insurance 36 9 4.7
Little Rock Direct Auto Insurance 36 11 4.6
Long Beach Only Way Insurance Services 36 8 4.8
Los Angeles Cost-U-Less Insurance 36 13 4.8
Louisville Crost Affordable Auto Insurance Agency 36 16 4.8
Lubbock Acceptance Insurance 36 9 4.8
Mcallen Amco Auto Insurance 36 10 4.8
Memphis Direct Auto Insurance 37 12 4.9
Mesa Acceptance Insurance 37 11 4.8
Miami SOL Insurance Agency 36 14 5
Milwaukee Frank Medina Insurance 36 8 4.7
Minneapolis BlueJay Insurance Agency, Inc. 36 8 4.9
Mobile Acceptance Insurance 36 5 4.9
Nashville Acceptance Insurance 36 11 4.9
New Orleans Freeway Insurance 36 13 4.8
New York Silverline Insurance 36 13 4.8
Newark Halsey Street Agency Inc. 36 6 4.5
Oakland Near By Insurance Agency 36 9 5
Oklahoma City Thrive Insurance 36 9 4.8
Omaha Alvarez Insurance Agency 36 12 4.5
Orlando Acceptance Insurance 36 9 5
Philadelphia Haven Affordable Auto Insurance Philadelphia 36 13 4.9
Phoenix Acceptance Insurance 36 10 4.9
Pittsburgh Brown Insurance Agency 36 9 4.9
Plano AZ Auto Insurance 36 9 4.7
Portland Bridge City Insurance 36 10 4.9
Providence Cross Insurance 36 9 4.9
Raleigh Raleigh Insurance Group 36 10 5
Reno A Abana Auto Insurance 36 9 4.8
Richmond Capitol Square Insurance 36 8 4.9
Riverside Riverside Insurance Agency Inc. 37 10 4.8
Rochester Freeway Insurance 36 10 4.9
Sacramento Cost-U-Less Insurance 36 11 4.75
Salt Lake City Community Insurance Utah 36 6 4.7
San Antonio Leal Insurance Services, LLC 36 13 4.9
San Diego Let's Insure 36 7 5
San Francisco Donald Browne Insurance Services, formerly, John A Morton Insurance Agency 36 10 4.9
San Jose Acceptance Insurance 36 8 4.9
Sarasota Multi Insurance Services 36 8 4.75
Seattle Brown & Brown DBA Spangler Insurance 36 7 4.9
Spokane Western Insurance Associates 36 8 4.9
St. Louis Norrell Insurance Agency 36 9 4.9
St. Petersburg 5-Star Insurance 36 9 4.8
Syracuse MY Agency of CNY, Inc 36 6 4.7
Tacoma Farmers Insurance - Anel Galicia Pichardo 36 12 4.9
Tallahassee Acceptance Insurance 36 5 4.7
Tampa Insurance Direct 36 13 4.8
Tucson Acceptance Insurance 36 8 4.8
Tulsa Cheapest Auto Insurance 36 11 4.85
Washington Crystal Insurance Group, Inc. 36 11 4.6
Wichita M & M Insurance Associates 36 5 4.3
Worcester Zawada Insurance Agency 36 6 4.8

Canada

10 metros · led by brokerages rather than storefront networks
Insurance local pack summary by metro, August 2026
MetroHolds the most slots SlotsBusinessesMedian rating
Calgary Sharp Insurance 36 7 4.6
Edmonton Sharp Insurance - Edmonton 36 14 4.35
Hamilton Begin Insurance Inc. Hamilton 36 7 4.4
Mississauga Insure With Dolly 36 9 4.8
Montreal YouSet 36 7 4.8
Ottawa Aviva Canada 33 7 4.9
Saskatoon Cherry Insurance Ltd 36 7 4.2
Toronto Mitch Insurance Brokers 36 14 4.7
Vancouver AMC Insurance Service - Yaletown (All Risk Insurance Agencies) 36 11 4.5
Winnipeg Westland Insurance 36 6 4.4

Not in your metro's map pack?

We run these 12 searches in your markets and show which slots you hold, where your rating sits against the local field, and which competitors are appearing that you have not noticed.

Get your scorecard
Free · 2-day turnaround · no call required