Allstate has the highest organic search visibility for car insurance in 44 of the 50 US states we measure.
In the AI Overview sitting above those results, GEICO is the most-cited source in 24 states. Allstate leads in 10.
Market leadership, October 2026
| Brand | States led on organic | States led on citations |
|---|---|---|
| Allstate | 44 | 10 |
| Progressive | 6 | 9 |
| GEICO | 0 | 24 |
| Liberty Mutual | 0 | 7 |
Organic visibility is a position-weighted share of the top ten, indexed to the leader in each state. Citation share counts the sources credited beneath a Google AI Overview. They are measured separately because they behave differently.
The most-cited sources
| Source | Citations | Share | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| NerdWallet | 405 | 7.0% | Comparison sites |
| Insurify | 404 | 7.0% | Comparison sites |
| YouTube | 378 | 6.5% | Forums and video |
| US News | 345 | 6.0% | Publishers |
| GEICO | 341 | 5.9% | Insurers |
| Progressive | 304 | 5.2% | Insurers |
An AI Overview appeared on 81.7% of these searches, citing an average of 7.2 sources.
Method
1,064 car insurance searches captured October 2026 through geo-targeted live SERP retrieval across 50 US states, 6 Canadian provinces and 109 metros. Brands and source types are attributed through a published entity taxonomy maintained by hand and republished each edition.
Full method: https://insuranceseosem.com/about/#methodology
The car insurance board, by state: https://insuranceseosem.com/index/auto/