The Visibility Index
Home / Research / Allstate leads US car insurance search. GEICO leads the AI answer.

Allstate leads US car insurance search. GEICO leads the AI answer.

Allstate has the highest organic search visibility for car insurance in 44 of the 50 US states we measure.

In the AI Overview sitting above those results, GEICO is the most-cited source in 24 states. Allstate leads in 10.

Market leadership, October 2026

BrandStates led on organicStates led on citations
Allstate4410
Progressive69
GEICO024
Liberty Mutual07

Organic visibility is a position-weighted share of the top ten, indexed to the leader in each state. Citation share counts the sources credited beneath a Google AI Overview. They are measured separately because they behave differently.

The most-cited sources

SourceCitationsShareType
NerdWallet4057.0%Comparison sites
Insurify4047.0%Comparison sites
YouTube3786.5%Forums and video
US News3456.0%Publishers
GEICO3415.9%Insurers
Progressive3045.2%Insurers

An AI Overview appeared on 81.7% of these searches, citing an average of 7.2 sources.

Method

1,064 car insurance searches captured October 2026 through geo-targeted live SERP retrieval across 50 US states, 6 Canadian provinces and 109 metros. Brands and source types are attributed through a published entity taxonomy maintained by hand and republished each edition.

Full method: https://insuranceseosem.com/about/#methodology

The car insurance board, by state: https://insuranceseosem.com/index/auto/

SP

Suren Pillai

Principal at Insurance SEO SEM, Calgary. Ten years in insurance search, including digital marketing roles inside AXA and Sompo and at national Canadian brokerages. Runs the monthly captures behind the Insurance Visibility Index.

Want this for your keywords and your markets?

We run the same capture on your query set, your states and your lines, and send you the table with your competitors on it.

Get your visibility scorecard
Free · 2-day turnaround · no call required